There is an entire genre of blog posts in which a heavier or otherwise nonconforming woman complains about thinner or otherwise more conforming women talking about dieting/ostentatiously refusing food/otherwise trumpeting their conformity in a way the blogger finds rude. Awareified by my blog reading, I knew that recently I was in a bit of a thorny interpersonal situation, and I didn't manage to part the brambles in the most delicate way possible, so I wanted to ask my commentariat for their advice on the best way to handle it.
I went on a little recruiting outing with some other interns at my second volunteer gig (not the one with the clinical psychologist I mentioned in the last post). We stopped to get lunch, and one of the other interns and I rejected the pizza and went to the buffet/grocery store. She's a little fat, not extremely. At this point, although I'd like to shave off a little more weight, I'm not most people's idea of "needs to lose weight," and it's always been the case that my body shape is such that it looks to a lot of people like I'm lighter than I am and have less body fat than I do. Plus, I was wearing a skirt, and since I carry weight in my thighs, if you can't see them, I look quite thin. But, like I said, I would like to shave off a little more weight, I try to diet in part to keep Boeuf motivational company on his, and for that matter I've been flaky enough that lately all "dieting" has really meant is that I try to run calorie deficits on some days in order to make up for the inevitable others on which I do something like eat foie gras at Jean-Georges and then have all-you-can-eat sushi at night, and in this manner at least prevent myself from gaining too much weight.
So at the store I made a beeline for a favorite diet food of mine, what I call special sandwiches. They're these little pita-wrapped salads of vegetable protein, nonfat mayonnaise, cabbage, carrot, and celery. A lot of them are a little bland, although I've come to like them, maybe mostly through familiarity, and their fillingness/calorie ratio is extremely high. But they're very expensive, and while I came to like them by buying them at health food stores where they presumably sold and were restocked faster, when you buy them at regular stores there's a considerable risk they'll be a little spoiled; the expiration date on the packages is way too generous. I usually eat them anyway (! I told you I had a strong constitution and it was hard to make me sick). But I wouldn't recommend that anyone without my die hard loyalty to special sandwiches buy them somewhere they didn't think they got restocked fast, and I wouldn't recommend them as food to anyone without my particular set of concerns; I like them, but if you're not worried about calories, there's even another brand of prewrapped vegetable protein sandwiches that's fattier and tastier.
This girl saw me intent on one particular purchase and she followed me with some interest, saying, "what's that?" like she might have bought some too. I wanted to dissuade her from getting them, and knowing I was walking into a thicket I cast about my mind for the right thing to say, but just couldn't find it, so I said, "I'm getting these because I'm on a diet, and they're really low calorie, but I wouldn't recommend them to other people; they're awfully expensive for the amount of food and they're a little bland; I just like them anyway."
She responded, "Why are YOU on a diet?"
I certainly didn't want to get in a big conversation about my weird perfectionism with someone substantially heavier than I am, so I just awkwardly shrugged the question away: "I don't know," I said.
I actually think she was fairly rude herself. That was a question there was a decent chance I wasn't going to want to answer, and while there is a social convention in some subset of peer/peer women-alone-together situations that you can often be expected to get to chatty intimacy about sex/body stuff pretty quickly, her tone wasn't really, "ah, get on with you, why are you on a diet, girlfriend, you look great" but more like, "you weird irrational alien, don't you know you're thin?"
But leaving that aside, I knew beforehand I was opening the door to some awkwardness like this; normally I just wouldn't mention anything about dieting but I wanted to find a way to communicate to her that while *I* had a reason for buying the sandwiches, I wouldn't recommend them to people who weren't making some effort at calorie restriction. So my question is: what should I have said? I asked Boeuf, and he suggested, "I'm trying to watch my calories today," which still strikes me as raising the issue, but he thinks it's an improvement because it doesn't suggest that I'm trying to reduce my size, merely trying to maintain it. Does anyone have any other suggestions?
Recent Comments